An introduction to the criminalization of knowingly transmitting aids

It is an affirmative defense that the sexual activity took place between consenting adults after full disclosure by the accused of the risk of HIV transmission. It is also an affirmative defense that the transfer of body fluid, tissue or organs occurred after advice from a licensed physician that the accused was noninfectious. The actual transmission of HIV is not a required element of this crime. It is an affirmative defense that the person exposed knew the infected person was infected with HIV, knew the action could result in infection, and consented with that knowledge.

An introduction to the criminalization of knowingly transmitting aids

Essay: Criminalization of Knowlingly Transmitting AIDS

Territories, Federal government, and the U. Congress on September 23,by Rep. It was the first piece of federal legislation to address HIV criminalization and provided incentives for states to reconsider laws and practices that target people with HIV for consensual sexual activity and conduct that poses no risk of HIV transmission.


Under that statute, Daniel James Rick, despite having informed his sexual partner of his HIV status, was charged with attempted first-degree assault with great bodily harm. His conviction in the trial court was overturned on appeal, and the Supreme Court of Minnesota on August 21,agreed that the prosecutor had misapplied the statute's provision meant to address the transmission of a communicable disease in non-sexual contexts, such as sperm or organ donations.

Criminal transmission of HIV - Wikipedia

For 16 years it allowed anyone with HIV exposing another person without disclosing his or her positive status, whether infection occurred or not, to be convicted of a class B felony, i.

Senate File redefines crimes for transmission of HIV, but also hepatitistuberculosis and meningococcal disease and introduces a tiered-system of sentencing: Intentional transmission remains a class B felony, but if there is intent and no transmission it is a class D felony, the same as unintentional transmission.

On 27 FebruarySF passed the Iowa Senate by a margin [35] attracting national media attention. Thomas Guerrawho became the first person in the state of California to be convicted for intentionally infecting another individual with HIV.

In court, prosecutors presented 11, text messages and 36 audio clips to support their case against Guerra. Since then, Guerra has been accused of intentionally exposing dozens of other men to the HIV. His saliva was considered to be the dangerous instrument for the purpose of the "aggravated" portion of the charge People v.

Plunkett, New York Court of Appeals. Army, was ordered in November to inform any sexual partner of his HIV status. After he had sex with a year-old male who became infected, he was charged in June with " crimes against natureassault and assault with a deadly weapon".

Assault With a Deadly Weapon

He was sentenced to serve 40 months in military prisona reduction in rank to private, and a dishonorable discharge. Navy officer and Catholic priest pleaded guilty in December to several crimes committed against U. Naval Academy midshipmen he was counseling, including forcible sodomy and indecent assault.

Charges of assault were changed to aggravated assault because of his HIV status.Spitting or transmitting HIV-infected bodily fluids is a criminal offense in some states, particularly if the target is a prison guard. Some states treat the transmission of HIV, depending upon a variety of factors, as a felony and others as a misdemeanor.

- AIDS Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome, better known as AIDS, is caused by the incurable HIV virus. AIDS is a deadly disease that deteriorates the immune system. There are two groups of HIV (human immunodeficiency virus), HIV-1 that occurs throughout . Criminalization of HIV: Spread of the Viral Underclass In many states, including Indiana, simply having HIV is a crime with potentially severe consequences. The criminalization of HIV is founded on a fear of something many people do not fully understand and the stigma of “HIV’s association with an ‘outlaw’ sexuality, anal. The criminal transmission of HIV in the United States varies among jurisdictions. More than thirty of the fifty states in the U.S. have prosecuted HIV-positive individuals for exposing another person to HIV. State laws criminalize different behaviors and assign different penalties.

Criminalization of potential HIV exposure is largely a matter of state law, although some federal legislation addresses criminalization in discrete areas, such as blood donation. The National HIV/AIDS Strategy, released by the White House in July , provides some guidance regarding the issue of criminalization, noting that in some instances.

Jun 23,  · Spokespersons for AIDS organizations, anxious about the stigma arising from criminal prosecutions, properly object to including HIV-specific provisions in Canada’s Criminal Code.

Essay, term paper, research paper: Sociology Essays

However, protecting HIV-positive persons from any criminal consequence of egregious behaviour can only add to such stigma since HIV-infected persons would then be treated differently than anybody else who .

Reasons for the Criminalization of Knowingly Transmitting AIDS There are not many reasons for the criminalization of knowingly transmitting AIDS.

However, they are very convincing arguments. The first and one of the most convincing arguments is because it will help stop the propogation of the virus. Transmitting Diseases Other Than HIV/AIDS People who transmit other sexually transmitted diseases, such as chlamydia, syphilis, or hepatitis may be charged under Texas’s assault statutes.

An introduction to the criminalization of knowingly transmitting aids

In Texas, a person commits the crime of assault by causing bodily injury or serious bodily injury to another.

Criminalization of Knowlingly Transmitting AIDS Criminalization of Knowlingly Transmitting AIDS Brief History of AIDS and the Criminalization of Knowingly Transmitting It Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS) is caused by the Human Immunodeficiency Virus .

Criminal transmission of HIV - Wikipedia